This is something that I wondered myself when having to vote... But now I am getting No votes for the exact same reason.
Is it allowed to update a profile even though you know that your update is still not complete ? E.g. I submitted an overview change for some DVD where I corrected some typo's and stuff. Yet, I got a No vote from someone telling me that part of the overview on the back is still missing. So I assume he would only vote Yes if I also add that missing part.
Personally, I think it should be allowed. Any improvement, however small it may be, should be approved even if it is clearly still containing other errors or omissions that were already there in the existing profile.

Some other silly No vote that I got was about me changing the SRP from 0$ to 0€ (locality where currency is €) without me going looking up the actual SRP. Someone voted No stating "what's the point? Either add a real price, or just leave it...". Well, I admit that this minor change is of little value and more of a nit-pick, but if I see the inconsistency, I can just as well submit it, no ?

Quoting Repter:

Quote:
This is something that I wondered myself when having to vote... But now I am getting No votes for the exact same reason.
Is it allowed to update a profile even though you know that your update is still not complete ? E.g. I submitted an overview change for some DVD where I corrected some typo's and stuff. Yet, I got a No vote from someone telling me that part of the overview on the back is still missing. So I assume he would only vote Yes if I also add that missing part.
Personally, I think it should be allowed. Any improvement, however small it may be, should be approved even if it is clearly still containing other errors or omissions that were already there in the existing profile.

Some other silly No vote that I got was about me changing the SRP from 0$ to 0€ (locality where currency is €) without me going looking up the actual SRP. Someone voted No stating "what's the point? Either add a real price, or just leave it...". Well, I admit that this minor change is of little value and more of a nit-pick, but if I see the inconsistency, I can just as well submit it, no ?

You do NOT have to fill in every little thing on a profile to submit it.  If you don't feel comfortable, for example, doing Audio, then don't make any changes in that area.  You should, however, complete any area you make changes in, to avoid leaving possible errors from some previous update (not necessarily by you), and so that somebody else doesn't have to come along and do a fix for something you left out.  Also, make sure that in the Overview area, and with Cast & Crew, that you enter those exactly as they are on disc, and make note of that in your Notes entry.

Quoting Repter:

Quote:
This is something that I wondered myself when having to vote... But now I am getting No votes for the exact same reason.
Is it allowed to update a profile even though you know that your update is still not complete ? E.g. I submitted an overview change for some DVD where I corrected some typo's and stuff. Yet, I got a No vote from someone telling me that part of the overview on the back is still missing. So I assume he would only vote Yes if I also add that missing part.
Personally, I think it should be allowed. Any improvement, however small it may be, should be approved even if it is clearly still containing other errors or omissions that were already there in the existing profile.

If you choose to update an overview, IMO, it should be complete so that some other user doesn't have to come back later and add what you knowingly left off. Otherwise what's the point of making the contribution in the first place?

Quote:
Some other silly No vote that I got was about me changing the SRP from 0$ to 0€ (locality where currency is €) without me going looking up the actual SRP. Someone voted No stating "what's the point? Either add a real price, or just leave it...". Well, I admit that this minor change is of little value and more of a nit-pick, but if I see the inconsistency, I can just as well submit it, no ?

I have no problem with this but with a little effort you could have Googled the SRP for the title .

Quoting 8ballMax:

Quote:
with a little effort you could have Googled the SRP for the title .

You may consider that an easy task for R1 discs, but it's near-impossible for the localities me and Repter work in. Therefore Repter's example is perfectly valid: he downloads a Belgian profile in which the SRP is listed as $0. He has no way of finding out what the original SRP was, he just wants to correct the currency to match the locality, thus €0. What's the point? Changing the currency to match the locality, I should think - I find that perfectly valid. IMHO, Repter is certainly not required to ascertain the correct SRP, as I know how impossible that is over here.

Quoting hal9g:

Quote:
But doesn't $0 equal €0? 

IMHO, these SRP's in dollars are still a remainder of when we only had dollars in DVD Profiler. I remember when we first got multiple currencies. I still see encounter "$0" quite often in various localities where it doesn't belong, and I always correct them. If I can find it, I'll add the original SRP, but if I can't, I'll just correct the currency. I really feel that that is a valid change.

Hal and Tim:

You ASSUME the title has an SRP. If it is partb of a Boxset it may well NOT have an SRP. But even so the 00.00 should still reflect the locality.

Skip

Ok, pal

Skip

Quoting hal9g:

Quote:
It seems to me that if you are going to edit any field and submit that field, it should be 100% complete and accurate, otherwise someone else is going to have to fix it and resubmit it again later.

That is not to say you have to fix every field, just everything within the field you are contributing.

I agree with one of the comments that was left for you:  "What's the point?"

I agree with this statement... if you are going to work on a certain field... that field should be done completely to the best of your ability.