Quote:
Quoting Martin_Zuidervliet:

Quote:
Déjà vu

PS. T!M Is Right and Skip is Wrong

Just can't stand to not take a shot can you?  Geez. 

Quote:
We've debated this many times before, but I thought the outcome was the same every time... The rules say:

Quote:
For English titles do not capitalize joining words such as "of", "the", "a", "in", etc. unless they are the first, last or only word in of the title.

IMHO, a verb like "is" does not qualify as a "joining word" (how can a verb be considered a joining word?), and as such, it should be capitalised. If you have doubts about this, please try and think what you'd for, for example, with the past tense ("was")... Would you capitalise that?

I realise that there are certain variations of the standard capitalisation rules that don't capitalise all forms of the verb "to be", but since the rules specifically use the term "joining words", and don't include an exception for all forms of "to be", I really don't think this particular variant is meant here. If it had, it could have easily been added to the listed examples... Since it isn't, I really feel the correct title for DVD Profiler purposes is 'Wrong Is Right, not 'Wrong is Right'.

But of course, once again Skip disagrees (probably just to annoy me: Skip is no stranger to voting blatantly against the rules when he doesn't like the contributor): "Incorrect title capitalization per Rules". Seeing the rules as I quoted them above, the explanation he gives is inaccurate at any rate, I thought...

FYI: the profile I've submitted this update for can be found under 043396-103368.

Quote:


There is an old TV show whose title will likely send you off the end of the pier.  It's initials are 'TWTWTW' or as it is sometimes called 'TW3'.  Here's the all lower case of that acronym:

that was the week that was

Now, how would you capitalize THAT?  (And I'm referring to the whole name, not the one word!)

Quote:
Quoting Rifter:

Quote:


There is an old TV show whose title will likely send you off the end of the pier.  It's initials are 'TWTWTW' or as it is sometimes called 'TW3'.  Here's the all lower case of that acronym:

that was the week that was

Now, how would you capitalize THAT?  (And I'm referring to the whole name, not the one word!)

I think the present rules make this "That Was the Week That Was", which looks decidedly out of whack.
Funny though that we have this special "title rule" only in English, for all other languages we are supposed to use the local grammar. For German that would mean capitalising the first word and every noun, for most European languages (including English) just the first word and all proper names.

I would propose that if a new rule is to be issued, to make it consistent across borders.

Quote:
Déjà vu

PS. T!M Is Right and Skip is Wrong